Global Leadership in the 21st Century: Revisiting the Values of Leadership
By Max Bouchet
The Covid-19 crisis poses an unparalleled test to leaders. Around the world, some leaders rose to the challenge, demonstrating a combination of compassion and strength, as well as the humility to follow the guidance of scientists and experts. Others failed resoundingly and revealed (sometimes, yet again) their inability to lead, with tragic consequences for the human toll on their country and social cohesion.
The crisis also revealed the weaknesses of established global leadership structures. The United Nations Security Council struggled to adopt a resolution on the pandemic and its global security implications, G7 and G20 negotiations stalled for weeks, and WHO had to scale back its operations due to the withdrawal of US funding. Some of these failures stem from a return to unilateralism and great power competition, but also – arguably – from a lack of leadership.
This is the context in which the Global Diplomacy Lab organised a session on Global Leadership in the 21st century during its virtual prE-Summit in May 2020. The concept of leadership is the subject of an endless number of books, articles, self-help manuals and compilation of quotes promising readers ad nauseam ways to “find a leadership style”.
In the context of the prE-Summit, the two panelists, Florian Bankoley, a Robert Bosch Business Executive, and Cristina Gallegos, founder and CEO of Skylarx, demonstrated that leadership is a matter of constant preparation and an exercise in day-to-day decisions. Moderating the session was Amarachi A. Igboegwu.
Traditional definitions of leadership emphasise courage, leading from the front and total self-confidence. As a Frenchman, my vision of leadership tended to resonate with the legacy of General de Gaulle, who, when France was defeated in 1940 and politicians had lost all hope, flew to London against all orders and famously spoke on British radio on 18 and 22 June to rally the Free French. But speakers in the session at the prE-Summit provided a fresh perspective and nuances on these principles. The Covid-19 crisis and the global challenges we are facing require a re-evaluation of the type of leadership we need, from countries and businesses to local community organisations.
The New York Times reported that Jacinda Ardern of New Zealand, Angela Merkel of Germany, Sanna Marin of Finland and Tsai Ing-wen of Taiwan have all led successful efforts to contain the virus. In her opening GDL Talk, Netta Ahituv explored the traits demonstrated by these female heads of state, namely a mix of compassion and strength. A Haaretz columnist, Netta is a member of the BMW Foundation Responsible Leaders Network and knows what female leadership means: she founded a women’s soccer league in Israel with the aim of using sports as a means of empowerment.
Leadership qualities traverse gender lines and the successes by the leaders mentioned above involved factors beyond gender, including culture, societal resilience and development. Male leaders such as New York Governor Andrew Cuomo also demonstrated empathy by calling on Americans to “practise humanity together”. The most recent tensions over racial inequalities and police brutality in the US highlight how the absence of compassionate leadership weakens the social fabric. From cities to businesses, leaders must help to reunite the country. Absent at the national level, 21st century leadership increasingly seems to be emerging at the local level, e.g. with Seattle Mayor Jenny Durkan urging citizens to “treat each other with the kindness and compassion that we all deserve during this unprecedented and trying moment in our history”.
During the Covid-19 crisis, leaders had to take decisions in a fog of uncertainty. When the pandemic hit Milan or Seattle, mayors made decisive choices based on limited information. Anticipating future events creates challenges for every leader, as Florian Bankoley made clear. “Planning the future” often feels futile, and Florian invites leaders to instead prepare their organisation to be able to react fast enough to meet change. The person who does not know the answer, but orchestrates the search for it, becomes the leader.“As a leader, you are a servant to your employees and your team,” Florian reminded the audience.
This requires leaders to create a constructive and encouraging environmentwhere team members feel empowered to bring in their ideas.Leaders must provide emotional safety for voices that might not otherwise be heard. Google’s research on “building the perfect team” highlights that everyone needs to feel validated to speak up without judgment.The plurality of voices also matters across age, gender and communities, as a plurality of backgrounds and perspectives around a table limits blind spots and groupthink, while increasing creativity.
Finally, teams need to know the direction they are headed in order to work productively. Team members need to be drawn in by a vision they believe in and to know where their individual contribution fits in. Cristina Gallegos described how leaders can walk backwards: they shape what success looks like and then create the plan that will lead the team there. They must also communicate their vision transparently and share ownership with others to encourage feedback.
This vision must stay aligned with a changing environment. Leaders need to constantly think how upcoming trends and technological change affects their team’s preparedness. To shape their vision, Florian invited leaders to adopt the “Zoom In and Zoom Out” approach. Leaders first “zoom out” to consider challenges and opportunities that can emerge in the long run. They then “zoom in” to identify the actions that must be taken in the short- and medium-terms to mitigate future threats or to benefit from opportunities.
To increase their preparedness for future events, some city leaders have created Chief Resilience Officers positions within municipal governments to conduct exercises that emphasise preparedness. More than ever, leadership seem to have moved from the national to the local level. Mayors, governors, and community organisers who stepped up during the Covid-19 crisis may well exemplify the type of 21st century leadership we need.
Max Bouchet is a senior policy analyst and project manager at the Brookings Institution, affiliated with the Center for Sustainable Development and the Global Economy & Development Programme.
Connecting with scholars, diplomats, businesses, city and community leaders from countries of the Global South and North, he researches the making of stronger local communities. He co-manages the Brookings SDG Leadership Cities network to develop relationships and solutions with city leaders to advance sustainability and inclusion. Passionate about the role of local governments in addressing global challenges, Max works to elevate the leadership and innovative power of cities in multilateral diplomacy.
Over 2018-2020, Max combined his research on global cities with a Robert Bosch Foundation Fellowship (Global Governance Futures 2030) and a Policy Center for the New South Fellowship (Atlantic Dialogues Emerging Leader). Previously, he was chief analyst of Conway, Inc., an Atlanta-based economic development consulting firm. Max graduated from the Paris Institute of Political Studies (Sciences Po Paris, France) with a Bachelor's degree in Political Science and a Master’s degree in Public Affairs.
Read more about his vision on city-to-city diplomacy here.
Florian Bankoley was born in Germany but spent his early years in Togo, West Africa, before returning to Germany at the age of eight. Ever since he has enjoyed immersing himself in different cultures and societies, enriching his perception and understanding of the world.
His studies and later work assignments have taken him to different European countries such as France, the UK and Sweden, and across the oceans to the USA, India, China and Indonesia.
After graduating from the ESCP Europe with a Master’s degree in Management, he joined Robert Bosch where he has held a range of positions. He is now head of IT for the automotive business area of Bosch, the largest domain in the group responsible for half of total revenue. In his spare time he loves to spend time with his family, and if time permits to read and exercise.
A strategist for the social sector and an expert on global change and philanthropy, Cristina Gallegos builds convergence towards people + planet + profit for foundations and businesses, strengthening brands through the power of well-applied purpose. A social entrepreneur, Cristina Gallegos has founded six businesses and has 30 years of experience in the field, 20 of which as an advisor to ultra-high-net-worth families and the non-profits they care about.
She is the CEO of Skylarx, a Triple Bottom Line, Los Angeles-based consulting firm with a presence in Denver, Brussels and Estonia, working to align public, philanthropic, and business efforts to strengthen the global society and the people who make it great. Skylarx works on projects targeting board growth, strategic planning, executive coaching, fundraising strategies, and merging business models with charity models. A lot of Cristina’s work tackles systems overhaul and grand challenges – from digitisation to inequality, the future of work, future of learning, financial sustainability, AI, the environment and democracy.
Ms Amarachi Adannaya Igboegwu is an Equity and Empathy Consultant with vast international training and coaching experience. Her primary goal is to empower both private and public institutions with a view to enhancing and building their human capacity by improving communication lines and promoting belongingness.
Her doctoral research study connects critical self-reflection and self-knowledge to the conscious teaching of elements that are necessary for dealing with structural racism. She has pioneered pre-service teacher training courses on the topic of conscious teaching, led workshops and given talks on the importance of critical self-reflection and the impact of implicit bias in daily life.
Find out more on her opinion on responsible leadership here.